Electric vs. Gas Cars: Unveiling the True Cost Debate

Electric vs. Gas Cars: Unveiling the True Cost Debate

The ongoing debate between electric cars and gas cars persists in online forums. Progressive car enthusiasts advocate for a greener, more sustainable future, while traditionalists harbor doubts about the reliability of these newcomers.

For those considering a new car purchase, the question of whether an electric or gas car is the better choice looms. While electric vehicles (EVs) have gained popularity for their lower environmental impact, cost remains a significant factor inhibiting early adopters. However, delving into real-world data can provide a more nuanced perspective.

Let's settle the discussion once and for all by exploring which option is genuinely more cost-effective.

Fuel Costs - The Shocking Truth:

The most apparent distinction between electric and gas cars lies in fuel costs. Electric cars run on electricity, typically cheaper than gasoline. In the United States, electricity costs about 10 cents per kilowatt-hour, while gasoline averages around $3.44 per gallon—a substantial difference.

To put it into perspective, filling a 12-gallon car tank costs approximately $42. If the car achieves 30 miles per gallon, a full tank provides a range of 360 miles.

Assuming the national average of 1,183 miles per month, gas car drivers would need over three refuels, spending around $138 monthly. In contrast, covering the same range with an electric car would cost nearly 40% less.

Take Tesla, for instance, which costs only $0.05 per mile, translating to a monthly expense of $59.

Apart from cost efficiency, electricity boasts higher efficiency than gasoline. Electric cars convert a larger percentage of battery energy into motion, outperforming gas cars that lose energy through heat and inefficiencies. For example, the Tesla Model S achieves up to 402 miles on a single charge, surpassing the average gas car's 350-mile range on a full tank.

Maintenance Costs - Keep Your Wallet Happy:

Another advantage of electric cars is their lower maintenance costs. With fewer moving parts than gas cars, electric vehicles experience less wear and tear. Moreover, they eliminate the need for oil changes, air filter replacements, and other routine maintenance tasks associated with gas cars. Consequently, electric cars present lower maintenance costs over their lifespan.

While not as maintenance-intensive as gas cars, EV manufacturers recommend periodic checks to uphold warranties. These checks typically involve tire inspections, wiper blade and air filter replacements, windshield washer fluid refilling, and other basic mechanical assessments.

EV batteries come with an 8-year warranty, and replacement is unlikely within the car's lifetime.

Let's quantify these maintenance costs. On average, electric vehicle drivers can anticipate spending around $4,600 on lifetime maintenance costs. In contrast, gas car owners might incur twice that amount—$9,200.

Resale Value - The Long-term Investment:

As the saying goes, a car depreciates in value once driven off the dealership lot. The same holds for electric vehicles.

Some suggest that EVs retain their value better than gas cars, translating to a higher resale value. However, with the used EV market relatively new, confirming these claims remains challenging.

Studies indicate that EVs may lose up to 52% of their value in three years, while gas cars and SUVs lose around 39% over the same period. The silver lining is that electric cars have a longer lifespan, promising a better return on investment in the long run.

Furthermore, as more people transition to electric cars, the demand for used EVs is expected to rise, potentially boosting their resale value.

Charging Costs - The Hidden Expense:

While electric cars boast lower fuel costs than gas cars, they necessitate charging infrastructure, potentially requiring additional investment.

Most EV drivers prefer home charging using Level 1 and Level 2 chargers, offering 3 to 40 miles of range per hour of charging. Home charging costs vary based on location and charging time, with some states implementing Time of Use rates—discounted electricity rates during off-peak hours, typically at night.

For on-the-go charging, public charging stations come into play, with some networks offering memberships for discounted rates. Signing up may be advantageous for frequent road-trippers.

Upfront Costs - The Elephant in the Room:

The primary hurdle for many contemplating electric cars is the higher upfront cost compared to gas cars. Electric vehicles typically carry a higher purchase price.

For instance, Tesla's most affordable model, the Model 3, starts at $43,490 before taxes. In comparison, a compact sedan from Mercedes-Benz is priced around $34,000—a nearly $10,000 difference.

However, federal government tax credits of up to $7,500 for qualified clean cars help bridge the price gap. Additionally, as technology advances and more manufacturers enter the market, electric car prices are gradually decreasing, offsetting the initial higher cost.

Depreciation - The Value of Longevity:

When comparing the costs of owning and operating an electric car versus a gas car, depreciation is a crucial factor.

EV depreciation reflects the difference between the new car purchase price and the offered price for the used EV.

While there isn't ample data to conclusively prove that EVs depreciate faster than gas cars due to the relatively small secondhand market, EV owners can expect a longer lifespan—200,000 miles or 12 years compared to traditional cars' 150,000 miles or 8 years. Fewer moving parts in EVs contribute to lower maintenance needs.

Range Anxiety - The Fear of Running Low:

Range anxiety, the fear of running out of battery charge while driving, has been a concern for some regarding electric cars. However, with the continuous growth of charging infrastructure for electric vehicles, range anxiety is diminishing.

Car manufacturers consistently develop EVs with longer ranges, reducing concerns about running out of power. Soon, electric cars may match or exceed gas cars in driving range.

Environmental Impact - The Value of Sustainability:

Lastly, considering the environmental impact of electric cars versus gas cars is worthwhile. Electric vehicles are more environmentally friendly, producing fewer emissions and utilizing renewable energy sources.

While battery production may have environmental impacts, recycling options are available, and research on repurposing batteries for other uses is ongoing. Overall, electric cars maintain a lower carbon footprint than gas cars.

While the upfront cost of electric cars may be higher, the total cost of owning and operating an electric vehicle often proves lower than that of a gas car in the long run. Lower fuel and maintenance costs, coupled with a reduced carbon footprint, position electric cars as a compelling option. As technology improves and electric cars become more prevalent, concerns about charging infrastructure and range anxiety are gradually diminishing. If you're in the market for a new car, considering an electric car could be a cost-effective and sustainable choice.

Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.